Masthead

Executive Cat Herder in Chief:
Bruce Bethke
slushpile at thefridaychallenge dot com

Chief Feline Officer:
Henry Vogel
tabby dot wrangler at gmail dot com

Associate Tabby Wranglers:
Vox Day
Guy Stewart
Vidad MaGoodn
Kersley Fitzgerald
Joel Rosenberg

Want to write for The Friday Challenge?
Writing Guidelines
The Assignment Desk
The Idea Exchange
The Recipe Exchange

Document Drop Site Information:
Web address: Friday Challenge Drop
email: fridaychallenge dot drop at drop dot io

Manifesto

The Friday Challenge is a very relaxed sort of workshop - slash- writing contest. Each Friday we present a new challenge, in the form of an idea, a question, or if we have an extraordinary amount of free time, a few paragraphs of a story. Then it's your turn to take up the challenge, run with it, and see where it goes. The next week we all get together again to compare results; a winner is declared and a new challenge issued; and so on, and so on...

The stakes we play for are very small. We declare a winner each week because excellence should always be recognized. We award a token prize because that makes winning more fun. But always remember, the emphasis here is on improving your craft skills through friendly competition.

The Official Rules
Or at least what passes for them around here.

Door #3
The closet where we store the prizes.

The Story Morgue

Have a story that's beyond hope and you just can't figure out what killed it? Maybe it's a candidate for autopsy in The Story Morgue!

Slab A: "Quill"

Slab B: currently vacant

Slab C: currently vacant

Gratuitous Plug

Monday, December 7, 2009

Ruminations of an Old Goat

It's December, which means a major gift-giving holiday is very close. In the spirit of public service, I thought I'd pass along some gift ideas for the geek in your life.

A few weeks ago, I wrote a column complaining how the future just isn't what it used to be. In particular, I had this to say:

So, how cool is it that I found the Retropolis Transit Authority site this week? The RTA sells t-shirts with a couple of dozen different retro-science fiction designs, including the one above. You can also go here and order the same artwork on coffee mugs, calendars, posters and what have you. Besides the flying car design, there are designs for the Space Patrol, Space Cadet, Space Piracy and even the Retropolis Ladies' World Domination Society (motto: "Don't make me come down there"). I can't imagine a better gift for any fan of retro-style science fiction than something featuring these designs.

Having written comic books, you know I have to toss out some suggestions in the comic book field.

I highly recommend the Girl Genius Omnibus, 312 pages of black and white steampunk adventure, providing an excellent introduction this fun series. Girl Genius has a Victorian-age setting, so you're looking at something with the equivalent of a PG rating. As an enticement, the most recent Girl Genius collection won this year's Hugo Award for the best graphic novel. If you give this to your favorite geek, the biggest problem you'll have is that your geek surely want to get the rest of the Girl Genius collections, too!

If you would prefer more traditional science fiction, take a look at Grease Monkey, a science fiction graphic novel for tweens and teens that's also quite entertaining for adults. After reading and enjoying it, I had no problems letting my son, who was ten at the time, read it. He loved the coming-of-age tale as much as I did.

For the fantasy fans, I'd recommend Bone: The Complete Cartoon Epic in One Volume. Collecting the entire 13-year run of the Bone comic book, this $30 paperback clocks in at 1300 pages, easily making it the best graphic novel deal I've ever seen. Bone won several comic book awards during its run and is entirely appropriate for all ages.

After reviewing the first half of A&E's take on The Prisoner, let me recommend you consider giving your geek the real original series. A 40th anniversary edition has been released on both standard and Blu-Ray DVDs. I was pleasantly surprised to find that Amazon is selling the Blu-Ray version for just under $50 and the standard version can be purchased for less than that. If your geek has ever seen the original series, they'll love this. If your geek has only seen the new version, they deserve to see the series as it was meant to be.

Of course, Christmas just wouldn't be Christmas for a geek if books weren't under the tree!

At the top of my recommendation list is Naomi Novik's Temeraire series. The first three books in the series are now available in a single hardback volume. (Ignore the low ratings shown for the volume on Amazon. Many people bought the book thinking it was a new novel and graded it low for that reason.) Novik has come up with something truly different, combining dragons from the world of fantasy with the Napoleonic wars from history. It sounds strange, but Novik put a lot of careful thought into the impact of dragons on traditional armed combat of the time. She does use the standard trope of a dragon and human rider bonding tightly, but adds armor, gun crews and even boarding actions, where a dragon's crew leap onto other dragons in an attempt to capture that dragon. If this sounds odd to you, just believe me when I say it all works. And if you'd like another opinion, perhaps it will help if I mention that Peter Jackson of the Lord of the Rings fame has optioned the series for movie development.

For the fan of military science fiction, I recommend Jack Campbell's Lost Fleet series. Starting with Dauntless, the series is a star-spanning retelling of the March of the 10,000 Greeks from ancient history. Trapped deep in enemy territory, John "Black Jack" Geary takes over command of a fleet of warships and attempts to battle his way back home to Alliance space. The tactics of space battles are handled well, with serious consideration given to relative speeds and large distances between ships. Also, five of the six books in the series have already been published and the sixth is due to be released at the end of April.

Oh, and if anyone is wondering what to get me for Christmas, I do still want that flying car!

Sunday, December 6, 2009

And the winner is...

The comments piled up fast for this challenge, which is always a Good Thing. Apparently it was Claymore's turn to get bitten by JS Kit's multiple-post bug. Don't worry, Claymore, we're all familiar with it by now and know you didn't break the rules of netiquette! Now, let's take a look at this week's entries.

Miko gives us three dimensional poem, one which can be read multiple ways and which has depth regardless of how one reads it. Much of the poem speak directly to me, being on the far side of 50, and generally gets it right. Very nicely done and, as torainfor said, a little convicting.

Topher wrote a Thanksgiving horror story; one I admit lost me at the end. The story had good pacing and drew me into Jason's situation. Instead of developing into something Twilight Zonish, it suddenly went off into psycho land as Jason drugs then kills everyone in his "family." In the end, my best guess is that Jason is some kind of psychotic who selects a family and begins to visualize himself as a part of the family. Terrific pacing, though.

Passingthrough's
entry is another celebration of family and food and the people who make those two things go together. Your story reminds me of many Thanksgiving dinners in my own family, though you'd have to substitute men watching football for working in the fields. For once, I'm pleased to say your story isn't quite the same peek into a totally different way of life. All in all, a wonderful story from wonderful memories. And I'm right there with you when it comes to instant mashed potatoes!

Torainfor wrote "Sufficiency Day," a neat little extrapolation on Thanksgiving from a Martian point of view. What I particularly liked about the story is that it shows family is family, where ever you live and whatever the circumstances of your birth. Fortunately, the family in the story is one I see mostly in stories rather than real life. The story didn't really have a traditional plot, instead being simply a slice of life look into a family struggling to actually be a family. Very well done.

Arisia's "Thanksgiving 2039" was easily the longest entry this week. I found it quite compelling, enjoying the fact of a husband who, year after year, finds he is most thankful for his wife. As I was reading the story, I honestly wondered how you were going to get 11 pages out of it. But that's because I thought the object of the story was to save Kate rather than to explore what effect this all had on Josh. I'm a sucker for happy endings and am glad Josh survived; because I still want that flying car, you know! Great stuff.

Excellent entries all around, but I'm in agreement with those of you who actually cast votes. Arisia wins this week for! Come on down and make a selection from behind Door #3!

Family Matters

 
Roots: The SMGFS (Sprawling Multi-Generational Family Saga)

Emily didn't want to be embalmed. In accordance with her wishes her body was cremated and the ashes divided, a portion to be scattered in Colorado, which she loved, and a portion to be interred in Minnesota, which was her home. For pure tear-your-guts-out misery there can't be much that beats getting down on your hands and knees and lowering the urn containing the ashes of your child into a hole in the cold, cold, ground.

Her mother, my first wife, picked a beautiful place for her. It's in the yard of her church, in a very old, very historic cemetery that dates back to pioneering days. There are entire generations of large families buried here, in plots that go on for rows and rows.

The group that always catches my eye is a small one, off to the side, in an older part of the cemetery. Two ornately carved markers stand there, made of some soft white stone that is slowly crumbling away under the weight of years and lichen. One is for Lizzie, who died on September 11, 1880, just a month shy of her 16th birthday, and the other is for her father, William, who apparently died just a few months after his daughter, at age 54. Slightly off to the left stands a third stone, small and very plain, with just a name and two years. It marks the final resting place of Sarah, Lizzie's mother and William's wife, who somehow lived on for another 34 years after the loss of her daughter and husband. I wonder how she did it.

I wonder what their story was.



The SMGFS has been a staple of literature since the invention of the novel. I remain unable to appreciate them, let alone write one. I sometimes wonder if this is part of the impulse that drives people to read and write science fiction: this uniquely American rootlessness, this loss of a sense of historical place, this profound disconnection from those of your line who went before. We have no history, therefore, we must invent one.

My family has never been much for putting down roots; at least, not in the past two centuries. We know that great-great-grandfather Gottlieb was a farmer, and we know approximately where in what is now Germany his family farm was. We know that he, Maria, and several of their younger children arrived in America as refugees from one stupid 19th Century war or another, but beyond that, the area from which he came was for much of the past century a part of East Germany, and when my father tried to begin searching for living relatives there in the 1950s he received a curt letter from our State Department telling him to give it up and not try again.

I never knew my father's father. Anton was 26 and working as a farm-country stonemason when he eloped with the 16-year-old daughter of a farmer and customer. While neither family seems to have minded that part much, his family apparently was unable to forgive his marrying a Protestant, and never spoke to him again. He died from cancer when my father was a child, after which my grandmother—

Well, let's just say she led an interesting life. It seems she had dreams of being an actress, among other things, and made it as far as doing character voices for advertising in the early days of live radio. She later wrote a book about her life, and according to other people who were there at the time, some parts of it bear some resemblance to the truth. She spent decades bouncing back and forth between the Midwest and California, and on her c.v. listed among her many accomplishments that she had studied metaphysics under Swami this, Guru that, and Enlightened Master somethingorother. More interestingly she was a longtime acolyte of legendary quack and con-man Colonel Professor Doctor Dinshah Ghadiali, and that certainly makes for an interesting ice-breaker at parties.

As far as my grandmother's roots went, they didn't go far. Her father first appears in our history as a babe in the arms of his young and unwed mother, freshly arrived at Ellis Island, and the family name comes from the kindly farmer who married the mother and adopted the son. If my great-great-grandmother ever told anyone who little Albert's real father was, it was never written down, and that knowledge is lost forever now.

In her later years my grandmother became obsessed with tracing her genealogy and spent an inordinate amount of time in old libraries and cemeteries, chasing down the only solid lead she had: her mother's side. In this effort she was remarkably (or perhaps suspiciously) successful, and eventually produced an amazingly elaborate family tree, as it seems the trick when tracing genealogy is to hook into a European royal family that has already traced theirs, and her mother was arguably the descendant of some sort of royalty. If you've read any serious history at all, though, you know the behavior of royals hasn't changed much in the past thousand years, and that sooner or later most European royal genealogies peter out into flimsy fabrications manufactured by sycophantic scholars for the benefit of the latest locally successful semi-literate warlord-king, for the purpose of legitimizing said thug's grip on power, and therefore have roots about as stable as Birnam Wood.1

Frankly, I'd have an easier time believing my father's ancestry is traceable in a direct and unbroken line back to Shemp of the Three Stooges than to Shem, son of Noah.


Roots, Part II: Night of the Undead Voters

On my mother's side, things get a bit more interesting. We know that we are descended from a long line of at-times wealthy English ship-owners and ship's masters; we like to claim kinship with Henry Jennings, because what the heck, it might be true, and how often do you get to have an authentic pirate in your family tree? We know for fact that we are directly descended from a particular English whaling ship captain who was such a rotten s.o.b. that all of his sons went to sea with him and every one of them jumped ship and took off with a native girl before completing the voyage; in that family line there are people all over the world and in every color of the human rainbow who share our family name and ancestry. Some people like to claim they're a brother to all mankind. In my case, it's true—or at least, they're all distant cousins.

Our particular branch of the family stems from the son who jumped ship in Boston and took off inland as fast as his feet could carry him. In time his descendants ended up in Chicago, and rose to prominence and affluence in the railroad business, only to be wiped out in the Great Panic of 18something-or-other. As a result my mother was raised in that peculiar sort of genteel poverty you sometimes find in people who were once rich and have not quite adjusted to being not-rich, in a big old house in Chicago full of maiden aunts and bachelor uncles, a disproportionate number of whom were named Charles. To this day, this peculiarity continues to contribute to my lack of understanding of my mother's family, as the telling of family stories always seemed to be interrupted by a moment when one of us kids asked, "Wait a minute, Mom. Are we talking about Uncle Charlie, Great Uncle Charlie, Cousin Charles, Charlie Z., Great Aunt Charlotte, or Grandfather Charles?"

"No, this story is about Charles Everett. Pay better attention."

As much as I have deep roots, I suppose they're there: in Cook County, Illinois. The old family plot is still there, and I could go look it up and visit it if I wanted, but I haven't done so in decades and would rather not. Excluding we children, the last of my mom's relatives died 50 years ago, and yet every November they still rise from their graves and go looking for voting booths. Frankly, it's kind of creepy.


...to be continued...



1 Genealogy, climate research: Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose, n'est-ce pas?

FAMILY MATTERS posts at 7 a.m. each Sunday and is dedicated to serious discussions of marriage, family, children, human sexuality, and all the other things that writers ignore when they cocoon in their offices and try to create fiction. This series will run until we either run out of things to talk about, solve all the problems in the world, or you tell me to shut up and go get some professional therapy. If you have a question you'd like to ask or a topic you'd like to expound upon, send it to slushpile@thefridaychallenge.com and we'll work it into the queue.

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Open Mic Saturday

Good morning all, and welcome to Open Mic Saturday. This is the place to share your news and perhaps do a little bragging. If you're writing a novel: how much progress did you make this week? If you're writing short stories: did you finish anything or submit anything this week? If you've sold or published anything recently, when is it coming out and where can we find it? In short, as a writer, what kind of progress did you make this week?

Or what else is on your mind, that you feel like sharing with the group here?

Fitz of Distraction

KillRaphael




Kersley Fitzgerald is an accidental cartoonist who'd still appreciate any inspirations you'd like to send her way. Email your Fitz of Distraction ideas to kersley.fitz at yahoo dot com.

Friday, December 4, 2009

The Friday Challenge - 12/4//09

Looks like we've got a pretty good turn out for our Second Annual Thanksgiving Story challenge. So, let's take a look at the tryptophantasies entered for this week. (Honesty compels me to admit that Vidad coined the word "tryptophantasies," I just used it in print first.)

Miko - Thanks Given

Topher
- The Dinner

Passinthrough
- Thanksgiving with the in-laws

The rest of the entries can be found at drop.io.

torainfor - Sufficiency Day

Arisia - Thanksgiving 2039

As always, even if you haven't submitted an entry this week—even if you never submit an entry in any week—you're invited to read, comment on, and vote for your favorite. Don't be shy about leaving feedback on the authors' sites, either. Writers thrive on knowing that someone out there is actually reading their words. The winner will be announced on Sunday.

By the way, I'm going to start clearing out files from drop.io on Sunday morning. If you didn't save a copy of something you placed there, let me know so I don't delete it!

And now for this week's challenge.

Letters to Santa

Anyone who's gone to any kind of department store in the last month knows that the Christmas season is in full swing. Retailers have had Santa Claus waiting to exchange a few of your hard earned dollars for a photo op, colored lights are up through out the stores and malls and Christmas music has been playing since the Halloween displays were removed.

Yes, 'tis the season for crowds and shopping and forced good cheer and spending money. There's even some mention of the birth of the Christ in there, too. At least, I think that's still part of the holiday. And who could forget the cynicism the holidays bring out? But what I'm writing about is Christmas from an adult point of view, minus all the magic and wonder that makes it such a great holiday for children.

The challenge for this week is to cast aside your inner cynic and dig deep to remember the child you once were. I want you to channel that child, to remember the magic of Christmas, to believe in the fat man in the red suit, reindeer and all. And then I want you to write a letter to Santa.

You can write anything you want, ask for anything you want, discuss any topic you want. As long as it's something the magic of Christmas and Santa can bring or do, you'll be fine. You can ask for things a child would want or things an adult would want.

As usual, we're playing for what's behind Door #3.

Ready? Set. Write!

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Deadline Reminder

The deadline for the current Friday Challenge, the Second Annual Thanksgiving Challenge, is Thursday at midnight, Central time. As I'll be asleep at midnight, Central time, those of you who have to snowdog their entry (i.e. post an entry past the deadline) have until early Friday morning to get your entry in. If you post much past 6:00 AM Central time, you'll be in danger of snowdogging it. Take advantage of that time if you need it!

Also, remember you can post to the Friday Challenge Drop if you want to enter but don't want your entry available to everyone in the world with internet access. The password is "challenge" to login as a guest.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Ultimate Geek Fu

His first episode aired on the same day JFK was assassinated. The BBC ran the same episode again the following week, just prior to running the second episode. But it wasn't until the second serial (multi-episode storyline) that the show really grabbed the attention of television audiences. Featuring one of the greatest and most enduring of all science fiction villains, The Daleks propelled the BBC's new science fiction series, Doctor Who, into an astounding 26 regular broadcast seasons and two theatrical release movies. Canceled after the 26th season, the Doctor refused to die.

In May of 1996, Doctor Who returned in a made-for-TV movie. It was shown first, surprisingly, on Fox in the U.S. Had the ratings been reasonable, Fox was prepared to move forward with an American-made version of Doctor Who. Those plans were scrapped when only 5.5 million viewers tuned in for the movie.

All hope of seeing the Doctor return to a regular series seemed gone until 2003, forty years after the launch of the original series. The BBC announced they were going to launch a new series, changing from the old format of four episode serials to an hour long format with single episode stories, along with the occasional two-part story. Utilizing modern special effects methods, the new Doctor has shed the guy-in-a-rubber-suit cheesiness of the original while maintaining the sense of fun and excitement that made the original series such a big hit.

As fans of the show wait for the new season and the introduction of the 12th Doctor, it's time to debate one of the truly important questions of our time. Which Doctor was the best among the first 11? For those of you who aren't die-hard Whovians or don't have encyclopedic memories, here is a handy short course on the Doctors to refresh your memory. And, to set my Whovian credentials, I made the list below almost entirely from memory, only having to look up the name of the actor who played the Doctor in the TV movie shown on Fox.

Willian Hartnell got things started. Of all of the various Doctors, I suspect he is the least well known to American audiences. Originally, the Doctor traveled through time in a time machine he built, having adventures with his granddaughter, Susan, and a couple of teachers he picked up on earth in the very first serial. Hartnell played the Doctor as somewhat remote and stern, though he mellowed as the show progressed. Declining health forced Hartnell to leave the series after three seasons.

Peter Cushing, sometimes referred to as the "forgotten Doctor," played the Doctor in two movies released in 1965 and 1966. Both black and white movies featured the Daleks and neither one fits in the continuity of the series. Those who have seen the movies generally say that Peter Cushing gave a wonderful performance as Grand Moff Tarkin in Star Wars.

Patrick Troughton came next, bringing humor to the role. The idea of a Time Lord being able to regenerate was created to explain the change in the Doctor. Troughton's very first episode introduced the Cybermen, almost certainly the Doctor's second most popular villain. After three seasons, Troughton left, citing the rigors of performing in a weekly TV show.

Jon Pertwee was the first Doctor to appear in color. He was also the Doctor during the most stringent budget restrictions the show has seen. With the costs of creating sets for alien planets and well as costumes and make up for alien beings, the decision was made to restrict the Doctor to earth. Pertwee's Doctor was exiled to earth by the Time Lords. It was during Pertwee's run that UNIT -- the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce -- was created to work with the earth-bound Doctor. Strangely, Pertwee was hired because he was a comic actor yet his Doctor was the most straight-forward, action-oriented of any of the Doctors.

Tom Baker is the first Doctor most American audiences ever saw. That's certainly true for me. Baker's Doctor was less predictable than any before or after, something Baker chose to do on purpose. At time arrogant, passionate, aloof and caring, Baker felt the ambivalence helped remind viewers that the Doctor was an alien. Baker stayed with the Doctor so long that it shocked viewers when, after seven seasons, he decided to move on.

Peter Davidson, at age 29 when he started in the role, is the youngest actor to play the Doctor. (Well, he is until Matt Smith, age 26, debuts as the 12th Doctor.) Davidson's Doctor was more restrained, compassionate and thoughtful than Baker's Doctor. This was done on purpose, to reduce unfavorable comparisons between Baker's very popular Doctor. Playing off of Davidson's youth, the fifth Doctor tended to react more than he did act. To the best of my knowledge, his tenure featured the only time a companion was killed.

Colin Baker took over after Davidson. The thing I remember most from his Doctor was his arrogance. While that was certainly an important part of the Doctor's personality, Colin Baker's Doctor seemed more arrogant than any Doctor before or after.

Sylvester McCoy was the last Doctor in the original run for the series. He reminded me of Patrick Troughton, both in his look and his manner. I only saw McCoy's first season, where he played a fairly whimsical Doctor, though I hear things got darker in the next two seasons.

Paul McGann played the Doctor in the aforementioned TV movie on Fox. Unfortunately, McGann never had a chance to get into the role. McGann's Doctor was supposedly half human and his companion, a woman medical doctor, had some rather abrupt lines that indicated some kind of love interest might develop between the two.

Christopher Eccleston brought the Doctor into the 21st century, introducing the time war, the destruction of the Time Lords and giving us the first real sexual tension between the Doctor and a companion. Speaking solely for myself, that last bit was the hardest part for me to adjust to. That, and Eccleston's accent. Eccleston was the first Doctor without what we Americans think of as a traditional British accent.

And finally, we have David Tennant, who is just ending his three plus seasons as the Doctor. For me, Tennant struck the right combination of eccentricity, compassion, arrogance, action-orientation and humor. Two of his three seasons included the same sexual tension first seen in Eccleston's Doctor.

There you have it, folks; eleven Doctors and a bit about each of them. Some of those bits are nothing more than my opinion, of course

So, who do you think is the best among these eleven men? And why did you choose that guy?

Conversely, who is the worst Doctor among the bunch? Which actor caused you to sigh in relief when he chose to leave the show? Him? Are you sure?

Whovians are a passionate bunch, full of all sorts of opinions. Be prepared to defend your choices.

Now, let the arguments begin!

ULTIMAGE GEEK FU runs every Wednesday. Have a question that's just bugging the heck out of you about Star Wars, Star Trek, Stargate, Battlestar Gallactica, Farscape, Firefly, Fringe, Heroes, The Sarah Connor Chronicles, Smallville, The X-Files, X-Men, The Man From Atlantis, or pretty much any other SF-flavored media property? Send it to slushpile@thefridaychallenge.com with the subject line, "Geek Fu," and we'll stuff it in the queue.

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Only 24 More Shopping Days 'til Christmas!

This being a blog about books and writing, it's time for some open-ended questions. Here in America December is the high-volume month of the selling year, and the book business is no exception. In the next four weeks millions of books will be sold, and then wrapped in pretty paper and bows and given to other people, who will tear open said paper and bows and express their absolute delight at receiving said books, after which they will place the books in positions of prominence on bookshelves or coffee tables and never open them again.

Even without thinking of all the innocent trees slaughtered to support this ritual, we consider this a travesty. Books are meant to be read. Writing without readers is like sex without a partner, or a day without absinthe. So given that the objective is that the book be read: what books are you thinking of giving to others for Christmas this year?

Conversely, what books might you be hoping to receive?

And finally, what book would you be delighted to find, either on the store shelves or inside the gift-wrap, but you don't think it exists?

Your thoughts and comments, s'il vous plait?

~brb



P.S. The Mrs has of course put in a request for Going Rogue, by Sarah Palin, preferably signed, so I guess I'll be going to the Mall of America after all. But thinking about this book renders me slightly astonished that some wag—say, Al Franken—has not already rushed out the painfully obvious parody, Going Rouge.

Oh wait, that's right, Franken is now in the Senate, doing... Well, I'm certain he's doing something important, that makes that whole ridiculous ordeal of last year's election worthwhile.

Monday, November 30, 2009

Ruminations of an Old Goat

Another week has passed and I have finally started watching The Prisoner. I've only managed to watch the first two episodes but can already see many differences between the original and the new version. Bear in mind that it's been over 20 years since I watched the original series, so please forgive me if my memory is faulty. Call me on it, but also forgive me.

The new version takes itself far more seriously than the original did. The original had a sense of fun about it that is entirely missing from this new version. I believe a lot of that stems from the very different approaches taken by Number 6 in the two versions. In the original, with some obvious exceptions, Number 6 plays by the rules of the Village. Essentially, he studies what Number 2 is trying to do and then beats Number 2 at his own game. This always led to Number 2 being replaced after each episode, yielding the recurring line "I am the new Number 2." By the end of the episode, Number 6 would have gotten the better of Number 2, paving the way for yet another new Number 2.

Alas, it appears you don't hire Ian McKellan to be only the first of several men to play Number 2. Instead of Number 6 maintaining his sense of self as we had in the original, we've got Number 6 showing signs of doubt and confusion. Yes, he's trying to figure out what's going on, but he's going about it in the tried and true manner of an action hero. This Number 6 reacts to Number 2 rather than making Number 2 react to him. He sneaks around asking questions on the sly, regularly slips off to areas that are supposed to be off limits and has flashbacks from his last night in New York.

And we all know flashbacks are just what we need to complete the story, right? After all, it works well on Lost (which it does), so it ought to work just great on The Prisoner, too? Through the flashbacks, we discover that Number 6 worked for some mysterious corporation as an analyst. Of course. This is the 21st century. We're beyond secret agents, right? Government is our friend and, as Ian McKellan has so recently told us in interviews, capitalism and corporations are enemies of the people. Or perhaps he was just feeding the publicity machine for The Prisoner, though I rather doubt it. Anyway, we slowly build up a back story for what Number 6 was doing prior to coming to the Village. I assume we'll learn more as the story progresses, until we know the full story. Yet we managed to enjoy all 17 of the original series without learning anything more about Number 6's background than what was shown in the title sequence at the beginning of each episode. If a bit of mystery was perfectly acceptable to TV audiences in the late 1960s, why is it assumed the supposedly more sophisticated 21st century TV audiences will be unable to handle it?

The new version has something else that the original didn't have; fear. Everyone in the Village fears Number 2, who is rarely seen without some big, beefy bodyguards close by. We've also got some other Hollywood staples -- explosions, guns and even a hand grenade that Number 2 seems to enjoy playing with every now and then. I don't recall ever seeing weapons in the original series. There were no bodyguards for Number 2 nor did anything blow up. The only "weapon" was Rover, the strange bouncing ball that kept anyone from going beyond the boundaries of the Village. Rover, at least, is still around in the new series. But the modern Rover doesn't just subdue people, it also kills them.

There was no attempt made in the original series to deny the existence of anything outside of the Village. The subject may not have come up very often, but there was no attempt to convince Number 6 that the Village was all that existed in the known world. Further more, there was a distinct feeling in the original that everyone except Number 6 was "in" on the plan. Anyone who confided in Number 6 would, in the end, turn out to have been acting on behalf of that episode's Number 2. In the new version, you get the idea that most of the people in the Village have played the same part Number 6 is playing. Their sense of reality is warped and they question what they think is real. It's almost as if the Village is a miniature version of North Korea or something. Paranoia is found everywhere, even among those who are supposedly part of the "staff" of the Village. This modern version of the Village, after watching two episodes, seems quite unlike the original Village.

There's one other thing I feel I have to mention. Perhaps future episodes will explain how this was done, but the current version of the Village has also had something flat out impossible happen. Number 6, along with two other people, went out of the village, which is in a desert, and found their way to the ocean. They actually get their feet wet, so it wasn't just an illusion or mirage. Later in the same episode, Number 6 leads the woman doctor out to show her what he's found. When he gets to the top of the dune which previously overlooked the ocean, all we see is more desert. In the original, nothing this impossible ever happened. I hope I'll receive a satisfactory explanation for the disappearing ocean in a later episode. But even if I do, that scene yanked me right out of the show by the sheer impossibility of it all.

Lest you think I hate the new version, let me say that's not the case. I won't really be able to judge the series until I finish watching it all, but I am both intrigued about where they're going and concerned about what I'll find when we get there. I find myself wishing the producers, directors and writers had brought more than the basic idea of the original series into the new series. And I wonder what Patrick McGoohan would have thought of the remake had he lived to see it aired. Maybe I'll have a guess once I finish watching the series.

In the meantime, be seeing you.

Monday morning follow up:

Well, I watched the third episode last night after writing this column. I still won't say I hate the new version. At least, not yet. But if things don't improve dramatically in the second half of the series, I probably will end up hating it. The third episode spent almost as much time showing with the points of view of other characters as it did showing Number 6's point of view. The original series stayed with Number 6's point of view through out, helping to build the character's sense of isolation. The approach the new series is taking does the exact opposite, as the person who seems most isolated is Number 2. That's a complete perversion of McGoohan's original vision for The Prisoner.

Sunday, November 29, 2009

Family Matters

 
Zombie Girl
Today I want to introduce you to an old friend, Mike Finley. Mike and I go way back, but the most important association is that for a stretch of years we were neighbors, and his daughter, Daniele, and my daughter, Nica, were inseparable.


Daniele is the one on left. Just look at that impish smile. Daniele was a natural-born ringleader. One day last summer Nica and I were sitting out on the deck, having a cold beer and talking about the old neighborhood, and Nica said, "Dad? How come all of my stories about Daniele end with, '...and we made such a mess, and Mom got so mad!'?"

For a time, Daniele was as likely to be at our house as Nica was to be at theirs. Emily used to baby-sit them both. But everything changes, eventually, and in time the Finley-Frazins moved one way and we moved another. Nica and Daniele stayed in touch for a few years, but slowly drifted apart until the wisp of contact was gone.

Daniele was always the instigator; the mover and shaker; the sparkplug and the one in charge. As a young adult she developed a chronic, painful, and ultimately debilitating medical condition, and when the surgery to correct it failed, she apparently decided to take charge one more time. On Tuesday, August 18, 2009, after putting her affairs in order, seeing or otherwise contacting many of her friends, going to a concert, and calling her father, she went back to her apartment, and downed a lethal combination of prescription medications and alcohol.

People react to tragedy in many wildly different ways. I am dealing with my grief for Emily by shutting out the outside world and focusing on my family. Mike and Rachel reacted to Daniele's suicide by creating The Daniele Frazin Finley Foundation, dedicated to suicide prevention. To raise money for the foundation, Mike wrote a graphic novella, Zombie Girl.

And that is why I've added Zombie Girl to the Department of Gratuitous Plugs in the right column. No, it's not a comic strip, and no, I'm still refusing to take paid advertising on this site. I will use the Department of Gratuitous Plugs to support the causes and people I believe in, and while I still don't seem to be able to do much to help Mike and Rachel, this is at least something.

Let's talk.



FAMILY MATTERS posts at 7 a.m. each Sunday and is dedicated to serious discussions of marriage, family, children, human sexuality, and all the other things that writers ignore when they cocoon in their offices and try to create fiction. This series will run until we either run out of things to talk about, solve all the problems in the world, or you tell me to shut up and go get some professional therapy. If you have a question you'd like to ask or a topic you'd like to expound upon, send it to slushpile@thefridaychallenge.com and we'll work it into the queue.

Saturday, November 28, 2009

Open Mic Saturday

Good morning all, and welcome to Open Mic Saturday. This is the place to share your news and perhaps do a little bragging. If you're writing a novel: how much progress did you make this week? If you're writing short stories: did you finish anything or submit anything this week? If you've sold or published anything recently, when is it coming out and where can we find it? In short, as a writer, what kind of progress did you make this week?

Or what else is on your mind, that you feel like sharing with the group here?

Fitz of Distraction

Revenge




Come on, guys, I'm running out of ideas! Send in inspirations for Fitz of Distraction to kersley.fitz at yahoo dot com.

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Deadline Reminder

Happy Thanksgiving, everyone!

Oh, and the deadline for the current Friday Challenge, the Second Annual Thanksgiving Challenge, is next Thursday at midnight, Central time. For those who have to snowdog their entry (i.e. post an entry past the deadline), you still have a full week to get your entry in before you have to worry about snowdogging as I'll be asleep at midnight, Central time. Take advantage of that time if you need it!

Also, remember you can post to the Friday Challenge Drop if you want to enter but don't want your entry available to everyone in the world with internet access. The password is the middle word in the link I've provided to the drop.

Critical Thinking

Seriously? It's Thanksgiving and you're reading The Friday Challenge? Modified First Rule*, people!


How's your NaNo going?


* The First Rule being that paid work trumps Friday Challenge activities. The Modified First Rule being that family trumps all. You know, unless your significant other is sprawled on the couch, watching football with one hand tucked carefully into the waistband of a pair of pants whose top button has been mercifully unbuttoned. And that the aforementioned waistband isn't yours...




Kersley Fitzgerald is currently (barring any unforeseen events such as snow storms or zombies) at her in-laws, being grateful her husband agreed to bring along his work laptop, her in-laws live five hundred miles away (although she's resolved to be less snarky about that whole situation), and all you fine hobbitses.